The Real Graduates of Notre Dame

The University of Notre Dame’s honor of Barack Obama was a historic event, a rite of passage. Television images of gowned academics in self congratulatory bliss eager to honor their symbolic president, against a background of useful graduates completed the scenes.

A day later it is hard to recollect a meaningful sentence either from the hopeful wish list Father Jenkins imposed on “the Obama” or from the self serving call to service from the self indulgent honoree.

Prideful stares from the platform committee affirmed their perceived handiwork, a President in their images, the panoply replete with an octogenarian priest memorialized in a fifty year old photograph as proof of their artistry. A caricature of the presumed America to come occupies the historic stage at Notre Dame. Gone is the America which shed blood to end colonial slavery, aging veterans who rescued Europe from Nazism and communism, the farmers who fed the world and the shopkeepers who scraped for profits to educated their children.

Instead, striped robed academics revel in an obstinate pragmatic relativism which has presided over a half century of cultural destruction. A prideful relativism whose empowerment would discard those individuals discourteous enough to presume existence.

But beyond the tedious rhetoric were true signs of hope; mortarboards of discontent scattered through the crowd, silent hands among synchophantic applause and a Laetare medal in thoughtful repose.

Outside the arena another story unfolded, a few thousand people and 40-50 graduates gathered at the Grotto; prayers, silence, and a shared alma mater witnessed a new hope for change, an antidote to the despair.

While the University may be mired in the past, the students at the Grotto have moved on, their graduation already a memory, and their protest the real hope to believe in. Life vs. Death? They have already chosen Life.

These are the true Graduates of “Notre Dame” class of 2009.

  1. Loved this article.
    “While the University may be mired in the past, the students at the Grotto have moved on, their graduation already a memory, and their protest the real hope to believe in. Life vs. Death? They have already chosen Life.
    These are the true Graduates of “Notre Dame” class of 2009.”

    for more information go to http://www.ndresponse.com/index.html.

    Commentary: Saruman at Notre Dame
    http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/may/09052104.html

  2. I think that this article is well written and thoughtful. I also had a friend in the ceremony with her classmates, that, although sitting through the reprehensible action of giving such a pro-death man an award made her sick, she did. She sat in silent witness with many peers who did the same, with baby feet and a cross etched into her cap. I thought, in a place where you couldn’t pray the rosary in defense of the unborn without being arrested, this was very brave and honorable. I just wanted to give those graduates who chose to make this public statement at the ceremony credit!

  3. The contempt you have for Obama is unbelievable. Am I the only one that thinks this post is way, way over the top?

  4. I have no contempt for Obama - but his actions regarding the unborn are contemptible.

  5. Those were true signs of hope.

  6. not just for Catholics anymore:
    http://www.lifesitenews.com/ldn/2009/may/09052707.html
    New Evangelical Documentary Exposes Abortifacient Qualities of the Birth Control Pill, Promotes NFP

  7. Oy vey.

  8. Mary Ann Glendon, the Learned Hand professor of law at Harvard Law School, the first person in the 133-year history of Notre Dame to accept its prestigious Laetare Medal–and then reject it- - , moderated an informal and excellent debate between Robert P. George, McCormick Professor of Jurisprudence at Princeton University, and Doug Kmiec, Caruso Family Chair and Professor of Constitutional Law at Pepperdine University School of Law.
    She commented after the debate that George and Kmiec had reached “a clear disagreement”, which was the purpose of the debate.
    What a wonderful term:
    “clear disagreement”.
    http://www.c-spanarchives.org/library/index.php?main_page=product_video_info&products_id=286645-1